Budget reaction: missed opportunity to advance the UK’s net zero ambitions

The Chancellor’s Spring Budget has sparked a chorus of disappointment, with many experts and industry leaders highlighting missed opportunities in the UK’s efforts to boost the green economy and advance its net zero ambitions.

While the Budget delivered on the supply-side with an increase in the latest Contracts for Difference (CfD) budget to over £1 billion – the government’s main mechanism for supporting low carbon electricity generation – some ague that it should have addressed the demand-side too, for example giving support to households moving away from gas boilers towards more renewable alternatives, such as heat pumps.

The REA points out that tackling climate change and boosting the economy is not an ‘either-or’ decision. The UK’s net zero economy grew 9% in 2023, in contrast to stagnation in the wider economy with GDP growth at just 0.1%. And yet, sensible measures to support this have not been implemented, it says.

Here we round up some comment from across the green economy in reaction to the Budget announcments:

Oz Russell, the ADE’s industrial energy policy officer:

“We commend the focus on connections reform in this budget given its centrality to increasing growth and decarbonising industry. However, with an election around the corner and a report published this week using the International Energy Agency’s (IEA) figures that shows the UK is spending the least among the top five major European economies on low-carbon energy policy, this budget represents a missed opportunity to provide much-needed support to industry on issues like electrification and decarbonisation infrastructure outside of the industrial clusters.”

Heatio co-founder Thomas Farquhar:

“The Chancellor has missed an easy opportunity to help the country reach net zero. Net Zero should be treated as a National Security issue that cuts through politics. We need long-term thinking that will encourage consumers to make the switch from inefficient fossil fuelled gas boilers and onto low carbon electricity technologies like heat pumps, that will ultimately bring down their energy bills while prices are lower than they have been. But we didn’t get that. The UK fits 1.7 million fossil fuel boilers every year but only 1% of households have an energy efficient heat pump.”

Gillian Charlesworth, CEO of the Building Research Establishment (BRE):

“While there was some good news today for individuals, with cuts to National Insurance and reforms to child benefit, this was not the net zero Budget the country needed. The UK urgently requires a clear, long-term plan to decarbonise our homes and buildings, and there is still a long way to go to drive the much-needed transition to clean heat. This plan needs to involve a raft of measures, from shifting levies from gas to electricity to encourage householders to install heat pumps, to providing guidance for local authorities so they can deliver retrofit programmes in each area of the country.”

Russell Dean, residential product group director at Mitsubishi Electric:

“We would have liked today’s Spring Budget to focus on supporting households to move away from gas boilers and towards more renewable alternatives. This will be vital to decarbonising the UK and reaching the government’s own target of 600,000 heat pump installations annually by 2028.

“To achieve this target, Mitsubishi Electric is calling for the government to rebalance the cost of electricity and gas. The cost of electricity in the UK is higher than the cost of fossil fuels. From April gas prices will be capped at 6p/kWh while electricity will be capped at 24p/kWh – which puts unfair costs onto households wishing to adopt and install heat pumps.”

Anthony Ainsworth, chief operating officer at npower Business Solutions (nBS):

“While the headlines will focus on popular policies, such as cuts to National Insurance and the freeze on fuel tax, for business energy users, there was little new information to take from today’s announcements.

“While it is undoubtedly welcome that the government is intending to extend full expensing – where businesses get tax breaks when investing in major assets, such as plant and machinery that reduce emissions – to leased assets, crucially he said that this would only be possible ‘when it is affordable to do so’. With no concrete timeline, it will be difficult for businesses to plan.

“Business energy users who had been asking for measures such as a reduction in VAT for public EV charging, increased incentives for energy efficiency, and sector roadmaps for net zero, will have been left disappointed.”

Will Walker, UK policy lead at Ashden:

“The country is crying out for bold government leadership and a credible plan to address the triple-whammy of energy security, fuel poverty and the climate crisis. This has to be done through sustainable clean growth. Any plan needs to be backed with the right powers, resources and incentives to empower communities, leverage investment, upskill and expand the workforce, and revive the economy.”

Glynn Williams, UK MD of Grundfos:

“The Chancellor’s omission of dedicated energy efficiency measures from the Spring Budget is a missed opportunity to boost government support for households and businesses struggling with high energy bills.”

Frank Gordon, director of policy, REA (Association for Renewable Energy and Clean Technology):

“This is a political budget above all that does not reflect the urgency of Net Zero and while we welcome the CfD budget announced alongside the Spring Statement today, and extension of the windfall tax on oil and gas excess profits, this is disappointing overall. In particular, the Chancellor had promised the sector a response to the US investment in green supply chains and manufacturing at the last fiscal event and to see very little once again on how we can ensure the UK does not miss out on the vital green jobs and investment up for grabs is very disappointing.

Brian Berry, chief executive of the FMB:

“The Budget could have been an opportunity to kickstart the housing market with house building rates stagnant, but the Chancellor has done nothing. It was also disappointing there were no new measures to help homeowners improve the energy efficiency of their homes. This was an opportunity to reform the planning system, boost local authority planning teams’ capacities, and review the financial burdens the planning system places on smaller house builders.”